Wednesday, November 08, 2006

Knecht/Windermere Conflict

It appears that the Knecht Cup conflicts with the Windermere Classic this spring, as both are currently scheduled for April 14th. In the past we've seen some of the faster non-West Coast crews such as Radcliffe, Princeton, and Wisconsin race at Windermere and if they do so this year that will degrade the quality of the Knecht field. This later date is probably a better time for Windermere since the crews will have more water time in and will be closer to their end-of-season speed. When it was held earlier in the season, it was hard to draw any real conclusions from the results, although last year Radcliffe did sustain their top ranking after Windermere for quite some time. It's not clear who will race at Windermere, although Wisconsin has both Knecht and Windermere on their schedule and Princeton, Radcliffe, Stanford, and LMU raced there last year. If any two of Princeton, Wisconsin, or Radcliffe go to Winderemere over Knecht, I suspect the other will also go (I think we'll see at least these three in California).

Although it's still early and dates may change, I'm not entirely sorry to see the Knecht Cup broken up. While I think it was a good opportunity to get the best light eights racing each other before IRAs, I don't think the regatta understood what they had and therefore were unable to capitalize on it. The lightweight race was an elite event occurring in the midst of a Dad Vail level regatta. And I do mean the midst. The men's novice four final was later in the day than the light eight, for goodness sake. The downside is that some schools with fast lightweight boats and so-so heavyweight boats were more likely to race there because the whole team was making the trip. Windermere, on the other hand, can't be beat for atmoshpere and the excitement of a match race. Visiting crews are treated like royalty. Sometimes, when you are at the pinnacle of your sport, even rowing, it's nice to be treated with respect. Windermere does it, Knecht doesn't.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure about your assertion that radcliffe, princeton, and wisco will go out to windermere...for princeton and radcliffe, knecht far closer and less expensive. My bet is that the lightweight eight at knecht may lose a bit, but will remain the place to be.

JW Burk said...

Yes, you make a good point - Knecht is much less expensive for the East Coast teams. Maybe I'm unfairly hard on Knecht, but I also think that Windermere, despite the cost, is attractive to these crews because it is much more of a showcase event. Few crews have published spring schedules yet, so I guess we'll have to wait and see.

Anonymous said...

Knecht cup is a horrible regatta b/c it is way too big and it tries to be everything to everyone. It should focus on just being a women's regatta for top lightweights + smaller DI programs, with DII & DIII. Or they should at least prune out about 1/2 of the events (Men's DIII 8, Club 8 and Varsity 8????) so that the site isn't mobbed.

Anonymous said...

Windemere does add some cost, but the sponsors actually pay for schools to come out - Princeton is using the weekend to participate in both regattas.